{
  "checkpoint_generation": "CM14-update210395",
  "checkpoint_update": 210395,
  "count": 50,
  "color_pairs": 25,
  "wdl": {
    "draws": 1,
    "losses": 0,
    "wins": 49
  },
  "score_points": 49.5,
  "score_fraction": 0.99,
  "by_color": {
    "black": {
      "wins": 25
    },
    "white": {
      "draws": 1,
      "wins": 24
    }
  },
  "decision_sources": {
    "candidate": {
      "model_policy": 492,
      "model_wdl_search": 596,
      "stockfish_conversion": 92,
      "stockfish_mate": 223
    },
    "reference": {
      "sunfish_nodes1000": 1379
    }
  },
  "forfeits": 0,
  "illegal_moves": 0,
  "legal_fallbacks": [],
  "cleanup_complete": 50,
  "termination_counts": {
    "CHECKMATE": 49,
    "FIVEFOLD_REPETITION": 1
  },
  "utc": "2026-11-08T17:17:14.608487+00:00",
  "completed_at_utc": "2026-11-08T17:14:53Z",
  "original_audit_sha256": "86ebb7d5ed4a9859f0b8d29fefb0b89032a6efca9b2643ccd99b6277b6d9c375",
  "pgn_sha256": "a0678f2954519cea338364c1f2e43deae57574d3345928ca4a816dae24e48a9d",
  "protocol": {
    "checkpoint": "CM-14 u210395",
    "checkpoint_sha256": "4cee1bf258f6061843f6073cd21d65f8981153ae47108551df617cb3053eea72",
    "release": "4cee1bf258f6-675c36654c3b",
    "opponent": "Sunfish",
    "nodes": 1000,
    "hash_mb": 16,
    "opening_pairs": 25,
    "forced_opening_plies": 16,
    "clock": "300+2 reset after opening",
    "neural_search": "CPU, 10-second cap, 6-ply depth, 4096-node limit",
    "helpers": "Stockfish mate, conversion and draw-save assistance"
  },
  "caveats": [
    "50 games, not a completed 100-game validation.",
    "98% wins; 99% chess score counting a draw as half a point.",
    "Small selected development suite, repeatedly inspected; shared CPU load; not an isolated harness ablation or general Elo.",
    "Four missing cgroup diagnostic copies; successful cleanup and available diagnostics verified.",
    "Earlier 100-game cohorts use different openings or assistance and do not establish a controlled causal gain."
  ],
  "matched_cm16": {
    "checkpoint_update": 369403,
    "sunfish_wdl": [
      33,
      2,
      15
    ],
    "sunfish_games": 50,
    "score": 0.68,
    "direct_vs_cm14_wdl": [
      8,
      0,
      42
    ],
    "direct_games": 50,
    "direct_score": 0.16,
    "scope": "Historical intermediate CM16 checkpoint, not final update665007.",
    "source_report_sha256": "c812269fa9b5031e85d251e52f8fca9ea226af7c7c16f0f0db45d9ce95517020"
  }
}
